News 
 Blogs 
  
 National Comment 
 Bogan benefits lost on smug intellectuals 

Bogan benefits lost on smug intellectuals

28 Dec, 2010 12:18 PM
They might have terrible taste in TV, but earn more and drink less.

According to the authors of Things Bogans Like, this newly monied, aspirational tribe are responsible for littering the cultural landscape with endless Pink tours, the music of Kings of Leon and Krispy Creme doughnuts.

I'd argue that their opposite number - the intellectuals - are just as culpable for atrocities such as the high price of inner-city housing, disappearance of bars able to seat more than 12 people, $7 loaves of artisan bread and Q&A.

Intellectuals tend to look down on bogans but maybe the intellectuals shouldn't be so smug. Things Bogans Like tells us that working in the mines is an apex of many a bogan's career path, as they can earn $500 a day plying their basic catering or construction skills. Sadly, junior intellectuals are not so lucky, being trapped in the low-paid vortex of part-time, contract and casual work in the creative industries.

As there are more intellectuals than there are intellectual jobs, they have to share the spoils. Thus we have intellectuals doing part-time gigs teaching at La Trobe, undertaking part-funded, postdoctoral work at Melbourne Uni, writing for broadsheets over the summer break, being casual producers at Radio National or novelists on the dole.

The junior intellectuals deeply resent the older intellectuals who took all the good jobs - the staff writers, tenured academics, the Booker Prize-nominated author, the film reviewer for The Monthly.

Under each junior intellectual's bed is a heavily highlighted copy of Mark Davis's Gangland, about how baby-boomer intellectuals hog the cultural, academic and media landscape.

This does not happen in Boganland, where the old bogans are more generous to the young, passing on their taxi licence or KFC franchise.

But the differences go deeper than this. While bogans are entertained by weeping illegals being detained on Border Security and receive their news from the hidden cameras of Today Tonight, there is nothing an intellectual looks forward to more than Monday nights. Then they don't just sit in a dark, cold terrace house watching TV on their Macbook; they are in 7.30ReportLand# where people just like them receive the weekly talking points.

On Monday night it's The 7.30 Report, Australian Story, Four Corners, Media Watch and then the biggest kahuna of them all - Q&A, for which they turn the sound down and read Twitter: "Malcolm Turnbull looks WRONG in a leather jacket" or ''Can Chris Berg pls sing Lady in Red - LOL".

Both the bogan and the intellectual harbour deep fantasies about appearing on their favourite shows and receiving validation from their peer group - the intellectual as a qanda guest, the bogan as a shouty, distressed customer who has missed his plane on a reality show at an airport. But it's in their nightlife that the difference is really clear.

While the bogan may make headlines with glassing attacks in a city nightclub or brawls at cab ranks, if you tallied them up drink for drink, the intellectual has a bigger alcohol problem. While the bogan binge drinks, the intellectual exists in a permanently sozzled state, with the hangover from the night before peacefully segueing into the first drink at lunchtime.

Have lunch with an intellectual and somehow at 9pm you find yourself still imbibing, this time at Jimmy Watson's (how did you get there?) where you have developed a hand tremor and the unpleasant sensation of an evening hangover.

Dinner at an intellectual's house is eerily reminiscent of the Wedding at Cana where wine appears as if by magic, with the intellectual liberating bottles from cellars, attics and cupboards, and port from under the sink. And certain intellectuals may secretly suspect that they are alcoholics - otherwise they wouldn't have found the week in Cairo for the conference during Ramadan so damned hard.

Of course, the two tribes have vastly different concepts of the ''holiday''.

As the intellectual has many part-time and contract jobs to juggle to make her $32,000 a year, the concept of having four weeks off a year is foreign.

She is employed for about 30 weeks of the year, yet paradoxically is always working - writing the next book, drafting a grant application or designing the next art installation. As a consequence, intellectuals don't really have holidays - they have periods of time when they are liberated from Australia.

The young intellectual will then spend three or four months subletting - via Craigslist - a flat in Berlin where she will spend her time with other semi-employed global intellectuals and come back with tales of "this really outrageous anarchist's squat in Kreutzberg" or this "really unbelievable fetish bar in Mitte'' or the "nude ping pong in the Tiergarten".

Older intellectuals with more secure jobs will take their 12 weeks a year in France or Italy, staying in the villa of a friend of a friend where they will gorge themselves on local cheese, olive oil, authentically nobly shaped artisan breads and, of course, wine.

So in conclusion: bogans earn more money, have shorter holidays, more generous elders, terrible taste in television and are more likely to end up in a bar brawl but less likely to be on the waiting list for a liver transplant.

Brigid Delaney is an author and journalist. Twitter/BrigidWD

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Brgid writes like an intellectual/academic with the sharp oberservations about the privations associated with junior, untenured academic lfe. Those comments vibrate with close association. The bogan contributions appear less close to home. How could she possibly omit references to flanelette - the acme of bogan contribution to clothing and manchester. Long live flanelette!
Posted by Long live flanelette, 28/12/2010 2:58:45 PM
Of course, both the author and the article are metrocentric. And being metrocentric confines one's mind to simplistic dichotomies and even more simplistic digital logic where the entire rich suite of human kind is broken down into that which is bogan, or non-bogan, or intellectual or non-intellectual. Is it stupid, sad, pathetic? Or all of the above?

After decades of exposure to both poles, and all the nuances in between, I find myself prefering the company of honest rednecks. One more earnestly urbane and erudite inner city dinner party and I will, most certainly, puke. Another dose of that sanctimonious mix of narcissism and gratuitous planet salvation and I am quite likely to sign up for a nitram and diesel enema.

No, find me a soul who has restored a 43 Chev Blitz, who can cut fence posts, split shingles, crutch sheep, pour concrete slabs and can comprehend all 14 tonal nuances of the word "aarh", and we will have a good long chat about the differences between the 1956 and 1996 wet season and the impact each had on the breeding of Wompoo Fruit Doves.


Posted by Ian Mott, 28/12/2010 4:18:31 PM
Dear Brigid, Re: Bogan Benefits Lost On Smug Intellectuals

I find your article both amusing and highly stereotyping!!;) I come from a working class background where my dad returned to study to attain his degree at night school as an UK immigrant with a young wife and 2 Aussie babies!!:) Yet he Never lost his blue collar heart & soul ~ he's like a Billy Connolly!!:) He made the Best Managing Director at work and combined fine dining out on occasions and cheering on his footy team amongst whom I would affectionately call Bogans ~ if you're talking about somebody whose a blue collar worker either by choice not to get a higher education or couldn't quite manage the degree of studying; doesn't necessarily make them any less of an intellectual than their fellow man whom has a degree!!:) In fact, I've met many men and women whom are intellectually inspirational, warm, caring and more socially in tune than these co~called intellectuals:) Most Definitely You Can Be BOTH & BOTH These Stereotypes Can Be Crass!!

You Definitely Can't Judge A Book By It's Cover ~ To Look At Me You'd Never Guess I Was A Heavy Metal Loving Fan in my 40's \m/\m/!!;)

Posted by Yathinkso;), 28/12/2010 4:29:20 PM
Dear Reese, Re: Porn Protest Goes Global (25 Oct)

Like to support your thoughts as a woman in her 40's, I find it confronting knowing our young children are growing up way too fast with the level of acceptance our society has allowed the $marketing$ and over~sexualisation in the media!! I'm a heavy metal fan also and find some music videos can be demeaning ~ support sexually passionate expression ~ yet the extent can be excessive!! I support free expression ~ Alice Cooper's portrayal of human nature/frailty & moods!!:)

I also went to a Blue Light Disco about your age (early 80's) and found myself trapped in a bear hug from a drunk man and when I eventually escaped, my so~called friends were jealous in place of comforting my shocked self!! So not only I didn't return due to the music Not being to my Hard Rock Liking ~ Also My Choice of Friends!!:)

Over~sexualisation is partly to blame as I find society way more restless ~ growing number of parents also taking risks with drugs/drinking & sexual activity can't help our youth with their hypocritical attitude!!

Reality can be hard to digest; remaining True to Yourself, you'll find it character building Dear Reese!!:)

Posted by Yathinkso;), 28/12/2010 5:21:30 PM
I've been noticing at parties and other social gatherings a distinct sub-set or cross-species that has many or both characteristics but lacks the capacity and desire for physical violence of a primitive bogan.

I'm yet to name such creatures but they don't fit either CUB's (cashed up bogans) or the bourgeois, cafe latte machine in the kitchen, 7.30 report watching bogan.


Posted by dusty, 28/12/2010 9:45:01 PM
Interesting conclusion. The conclusion i reached, was that us bogans were smart enough to get a better paying job, Had shorter but more entertaining holidays, (we like to go to places that are bright and were people are happy. Not hang out with deluded depressed euro trash.)

Have less boring taste in tv. Have caring and loving elders. And don't drink our lives away because we are bored with life. Thank God i'm a bogan.

And p.s Go to a few "intellectual" bars, See how many walk out of there with bloodied faces etc,

Posted by john, 29/12/2010 2:55:40 AM
Things Bogans Like - The Newcastle Knights!!!! In fact they've been propping up the club since it's foundation. Were they mentioned in this article? I don't know because i couldn't be bothered reading past a couple of paragraphs....
Posted by ming lee, 29/12/2010 9:31:49 AM
"...of the writing of books there is no end; and much learning is a weariness to the soul."
Posted by Ecclesiastes 12:12, 29/12/2010 5:41:54 PM
Can't wait now for the reciprocal rights book of Things Intellectuals Like written by a coupl'a Bogans.
Posted by Paul_concerned_citizen, 29/12/2010 10:18:28 PM
Hahaha! Excellent article. As a part Bogan and part intellectual snob (Bollectual? Intellogan??) I found this article well timed. I do find the condescending tone that some indie nannas and hipsters take to Bogan a wee big classist. Long live Acker Dacker, fair trade organic skinny lattes and flannel!!!!!!!

(PS happy new year to all)

Posted by MissAmande, 30/12/2010 9:16:01 AM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.



 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...