News 
 Australian Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 General 
 Dog breeders brace for inbreeding backlash 

Dog breeders brace for inbreeding backlash

24 Aug, 2009 06:43 PM
AUSTRALIAN breeders of pedigree dogs are bracing for a barrage of criticism as a documentary highlighting shocking health problems caused by decades of inbreeding approaches television screens.

The BBC documentary Pedigree Dogs Exposed shows graphic images of animals suffering with genetic diseases caused by the quest for the perfect dog.

In disturbing footage, a Cavalier King Charles Spaniel appears in agony due to Syringomyelia, a condition where the brain becomes too large for the skull and protrudes into the spinal canal.

Alsatians bred for dog shows are shown struggling to control their back legs.

Danny the Pekingese, a past winner of best in show at the famous Crufts competition in Britain, is shown sitting on an ice pack. Changes to the structure of his head interfere with his ability to breathe and regulate his body temperature.

The documentary caused a furore when it was broadcast in Britain. The BBC ceased coverage of Crufts, the RSPCA ceased attending the show and its major sponsor withdrew support.

Inquiries into breeding irregularities, such as mating mothers with sons, were initiated. Breed standards – the physical characteristics considered ideal for each breed by kennel clubs – were examined by authorities.

The documentary will be broadcast by ABC1 on September 10 and the Australian National Kennel Council, the peak co-ordinating body for local pedigree breeders, has hired a public relations officer "with the intent of reducing the impact of any fallout", council president Hugh Gent said.

Lee Pieterse, a leading breeder of Griffon Bruxellois, which are not featured in the documentary, is a council member who believes the documentary is biased.

Mrs Pieterse, of Dural, was interviewed by filmmaker Jemima Harrison but does not appear in the program.

"I just feel she did not present the side of breeders who do the right thing, and there are many of us," she said.

"She made us look so horrible. Yes, we've got some ratbags, I won't argue with that, but we also have a lot of people who spend a lot of money doing the right thing. Most conscientious and ethical breeders, if they find something wrong in their dogs, will do their damnedest to fix it."

Associate Professor Paul McGreevy of the faculty of veterinary science at the University of Sydney said: "The rules of engagement with dog breeding in Australia are the same as in the UK and most breed standards are identical."

He wants to see a review of breeding here and hopes Pedigree Dogs Exposed shows "pet owners why breeders should select for health, temperament and longevity" rather than for arbitrary aesthetics or to maintain exclusive blood lines.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Whether it's dogs, horses, cattle, sheep or chooks, there are lots of people who concentrate on breeding money rather than breeding animals that will find it easy to have a long and comfortable life in the environment they are forced to live in. There are plenty of us who can't cast the first stone at some of these dog breeders.
Posted by Mick, 25/08/2009 10:58:45 AM
All those lounge room animal welfare critics telling farmers how to feed and clothe the world need to look in their own backyard. And if they do not have a pet poodle there they have no authority to tell anyone how to manage the livestock put in their care. Woe betide ye scribes and pharisees notes hypocrisy of old which still exist today. Vanity not the need to make a living and feed a family drives this horrible blight on humankind.
Posted by Common Cents, 25/08/2009 11:17:25 AM
Never pay more than $20 (this won't cover vet fees so the dog must be healthy) for a dog and get a mongrel. Then feed it a meat only diet. Preferably raw meat at that.
Posted by Edward, 25/08/2009 11:17:39 AM
I doubt that the documentary is as biased as Ms Pieterse suggests. The tail of the dog in the photo has clearly been docked. She is probably guilty of brutality herself ... but there are none so blind as those that refuse to see!
Posted by slamina, 25/08/2009 11:33:46 AM
Dogs are for working and being a companion: breeds are to establish predictable physical and temperamental characteristics. Breeding makes looks similar too, but it is a step too far when looks become the only purpose of breeding. It always baffled me why people breed animals for show and their looks when those looks are often grotesque, some breeds are so artificial that they could not even sustain themselves without human assistance (eg, bassets) and the breeding increasingly harms the animals' health.
Posted by morrgo, 25/08/2009 12:19:48 PM
About time I think. No use hiding behind bias, it exists. All the squashed face breeds have breathing problems, and it's been known for years bulldogs have multiple problems, and many show breeds cannot reproduce normally. There are a few Australian dog breed societies actively breeding for temperament and health I believe. Now they can do another documentary aimed at horses, the caricature Arabs and quarter horses bred for the show ring that cannot be ridden, they are so grotesque, Arabs like elongated giraffes and QH like huge barrels of muscle on tiny short legs.
Posted by maiajustina, 25/08/2009 1:04:52 PM
These people are only doing this for their own egos and monetary gain - and certainly not for the health and welfare of the poor dog!
Posted by tigerdicky, 25/08/2009 1:05:50 PM
The monetary gain is a myth for those breeding firstly for health & the love of their chosen breeds. It's totally unfair to single out 1 side of the dog world. How many mongrels are out there that have been bred in the name of design that have health problems? Whether PURE bred or not, there are problems on both sides. The caring breeders do the right, responsible thing by their dogs & for the people that buy them.
Posted by getreal, 25/08/2009 7:26:13 PM
It is about time that dog breeders and the dog owning public woke up. We keep on breeding man-killer and guard-type animals instead of breeding for intelligence and compatability with an urban lifestyle. All over the world where the breeding of these dogs follow prescribed breeds people, especially children, get bitten every day by a neurotic dog.
Posted by jaimie, 26/08/2009 3:49:23 AM
Edward, if you only feed the dog on meat, you will give it kidney trouble!! very soon!!! Dogs need green leavy vegetables, meaty bones, other protein, eggs, sardines, a bit of full oats, soaked, etc - see my website: www.pet-affair.com.au
Posted by Bea, 10/09/2009 8:45:11 PM
1 | 2  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
We're not all bad...Lee Pieterse with her rare Griffon Bruxellois. Photo: Adam Hollingworth
We're not all bad...Lee Pieterse with her rare Griffon Bruxellois. Photo: Adam Hollingworth
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
MULTIMEDIA
24 August, 2009
23 August, 2009
POLL
Q: Should the Federal National Party split from its coalition with the Liberals?

Yes
(52.3%)

No
(43.3%)

Undecided
(4.4%)

Total Votes: 501
Poll Date: 23 August, 2009



 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...