News 
 National Rural News 
 Agribusiness and General 
 Finance 
 Carbon storage to rival wool: Garnaut 

Carbon storage to rival wool: Garnaut

15 Apr, 2011 12:49 PM
STORING carbon dioxide in the landscape has the potential to be as important to the rural economy in 2020 as the entire Australia wool industry, the federal government's climate change adviser, Ross Garnaut, believes.

Professor Garnaut addressed a public meeting in Armidale last night at the invitation of the independent MP Tony Windsor, a member of the government's climate change committee whose support will be crucial to the government's attempts to legislate a price on carbon.

About a fifth of Australia's greenhouse gas output is produced in rural areas, but this could be slashed if up to 14 per cent of the revenue raised by a price on carbon emissions was allocated to sequestering carbon dioxide in the landscape.

This would mean farmers would be paid for generating carbon credits by changing the way they managed soil, trees and livestock if they could show permanent and measurable change in emissions.

''It would equate to a new rural industry for Australia, as big as the wool industry was last year,'' Professor Garnaut said, citing CSIRO research that shows the potential for hundreds of millions of tonnes of carbon dioxide to be stored over time by changing tilling practices.

He visited a farm at Uralla, on the northern tablelands, with Mr Windsor yesterday to see how relatively simple changes in cropping and tilling cycles could help capture more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it in the earth.

''There is a fair bit of excitement about biosequestration,'' he said. ''Not everyone agrees.

But that's the way things work in rural Australia: some farmers respond to an opportunity and their neighbours notice and it works, then they do it. It takes a while to disseminate through the community, especially in an atmosphere where not everyone's trying to have clarity of message.''

The methodologies for measuring carbon uptake are still being refined by the government, but areas that could end up generating credits include enriching soils with more carbon, forestry, and improvements in management of fire, landfill and methane from livestock.

Legislation for the federal government's carbon farming initiative was introduced on March 24.

The debate about a carbon price has divided rural communities. The NSW Farmers Federation opposes a carbon price because it is expected to drive up some costs, including the cost of food production.

But the National Farmers Federation said yesterday that, while it supported the state farming bodies, it was working with the political parties to minimise impacts on farmers.

Mr Windsor told ABC radio yesterday that there might never be a carbon tax because the government did not have the numbers to pass carbon price legislation without the support of the independent MPs. ''I have a vote, others do as well, so you can never guarantee something until it gets through a minority parliament.''

Professor Garnaut said: ''What he's saying is what he's always said to me - that he won't make up his mind until he's seen all the detail.''

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Sure it would be worth a lot ... however there is no such thing as money for nothing ... some one will have to pay for it
Posted by Tom, 15/04/2011 3:08:10 PM
Until the first drought or bushfire. Then it all has to be paid back.

If this idea gets off the ground it will ultimately be funded by insurance. Everybody's insurance.

There will be a tight limit on the quantity of carbon sequestered.

Posted by Ted O'Brien, 15/04/2011 4:54:22 PM
Yeah, right, Guano, tell us about the $billions in stolen native forest carbon credits. These climate clowns just don't get it. If they don't do a very serious revision of the IPCC carbon accounting standards they can all go to the far queue. We have only been telling them this for more than 15 years and not a trace of progress.

And if it takes them this long to get nowhere on a key impediment, how long do farmers think it will take them to sort out problems once they have your whole farm tied up in carbon red tape?

So go ahead, fellas, sign up for this scam then sit back and wait for your grandkids to curse the ground you are burried in.

Posted by Ian Mott, 15/04/2011 5:57:19 PM
Garnaut, you ignorant git! Wool IS 50% carbon! Now convince your mates Julia and Bob to pay us to grow wool.

Nah, won't work. Can't have the peasants makin' a quid now, can we? Better to lock up land to grow timber that'll disappear in smoke one hot summer.

Posted by Brindi, 15/04/2011 9:02:38 PM
If Guano really wants to do something for the environment he should spend more time on his farm cutting his bathurst burrs which are a disgrace. Maybe he could use a biosequestrating hoe, excitedly.
Posted by what the, 15/04/2011 11:07:17 PM
much like trees ,you don't start sequeting until the scheme is in place . They said you have to show change , so if your already being conserving you don't get a look in . They did that with trees once so only the big companies could benefit . people had maintained timber areas for genarations go unrewarded but still pay rates on that bushland . This will be a big company get rich scheme only , & for a short time as it will send the carbon tax payer broke , wool is full of carbon & not mentioned in any ideas !
Posted by Ray, 16/04/2011 9:03:50 AM
Ted I ask you to take a look at what is going on with soil carbon, to really make an informed comment. It is not the top 100mm of soil that is the key to soil carbon , it is being recorded down to deeps of 500mm. And how is it gettig there is via the roots of holistically grazed plants. How does a bush fire destroy carbon 500mm under the surface. Get up to speed on what is really going with soil carbon.
Posted by holisticmick, 16/04/2011 9:22:03 AM
If anyone would have sugested to you 25 years ago that any of this madness was at all possible and that in the future just down the road there would be a tax on fresh air you would have laughed in my face. Laugh no more. To think that good men went to war to fight and die so that they could be taxed on the air they breath would make them turn in their grave. Its disgraceful and an insult to all that have served.
Posted by Loc Hey, 16/04/2011 10:11:14 AM
"Simple changes in cropping and tilling cycles"??? Tim's is a great example of grazing management for improvement in every aspect from improving soils to life in general, BUT you are implying that it is a simple change to me who has no fences as we only grow crops. Are we all to put up fences and watering points and feed the world on meat? I don't think so. Also is Garnaut implying that wool growing will disappear as carbon credits are so profitable then what?? Please there is no SIMPLE answer. By the way we don't own a plough and the most tillage we do is with a disc planter......maybe this is what he means.
Posted by Farmer, 16/04/2011 10:59:44 AM
Snake oil salesman straight out of the wild west.
Posted by John Niven, 16/04/2011 3:32:06 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

post a comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
 
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Picture this ... Tim Wright, right, tells Ross Garnaut and Tony Windsor about carbon storage on his property. Photo: Craig Schneider
Picture this ... Tim Wright, right, tells Ross Garnaut and Tony Windsor about carbon storage on his property. Photo: Craig Schneider
Related Coverage
ARTICLES
POLL
Q: Do you believe that Australian farming land is currently undervalued?

Yes
(46.1%)

No
(40%)

Rural land prices are where they should be
(13.8%)

Total Votes: 427
Poll Date: 11 April, 2011

Most popular articles



Straight Furrow







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

More Ways to Read

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...